I percolated all week about which column to write: “Isabel’s Kitchen” or “Food for Thought.” Food for Thought won because the subject matter is urgent. And, truthfully, I hesitate to write this because the topic is also dark, but hiding one’s head in the sand isn’t a good idea either. Apparently, science fiction isn’t going to be fiction much longer.
If you’ve read this column for a while, you know artificial intelligence fascinates me, and has ever since I read futurist Ray Kurzweil’s book “The Singularity Is Near” years ago. I use AI often; it thrills and delights me, and I’m awestruck by what it can do.
In an effort to understand “this thing,” I’ve read numerous books and publications, some scientific, and watched countless YouTube videos. Yet the more I learn, the less I know, because views about how AI will influence society are polarized. A few months ago, I surrendered my quest to understand AI’s long-term implications to halt my tumble down a rabbit hole.
But then I stumbled across Bill Gates’ Aug. 26 essay titled “The Turbulent AI Era Is Here. The Choices We Make Now Are Critical.” I was relieved to finally get some straight answers to my questions about job losses, taxation, regulation, safety, and whether AI will ultimately transform society for the better or pose extraordinary dangers. I didn’t come away knowing “The Truth,” but for the first time, I felt as if someone put the pieces together in a way that made sense.
Gates is not an AI doomsayer; in fact, he’s quite the opposite. He believes AI could dramatically improve the lives of people around the world through medicine, education, and scientific research. That makes his warnings about its dangers all the more striking.
After I sat with the essay for a while, my friend Kyle sent me a link to an interview with Gates, conducted on Sept. 29 by New York Times host and columnist Ezra Klein: “Bill Gates’s Blunt Warning on A.I.” Klein peppers him with questions about the essay.
I like to keep this column’s tone upbeat, but we need to see what’s hurtling toward us.
Gates says AI crossed dangerous thresholds in cyber and biological capabilities early this year. He warns that increasingly powerful AI could help bad actors carry out cyberattacks that disrupt the systems we depend on and seriously affect hospitals, financial institutions, water systems, power grids, and those that manage government benefits. They might also use AI to create biological weapons that could kill millions. He says, “This makes nuclear weapons look like nothing.”
Yes, you read that right.
While the Gates Foundation continues its work in global health and other areas, Gates says he has decided to use his public voice to sound the alarm about these risks. In the interview, he says, “But it’s the combination of having crossed every dangerous threshold, without a doubt, and a complete lack of engagement outside of the industry.”
Gates says governmental oversight and safeguards exist around other dangerous technologies, but nothing similar exists today to adequately oversee advanced AI’s most dangerous capabilities.
He argues that this conversation needs to expand beyond Silicon Valley’s AI companies and include people from many sectors and walks of life. In other words, this conversation belongs at our kitchen tables, too.
Here are my moral and ethical questions: If a company knowingly releases technology capable of causing catastrophic harm, when does releasing that technology become reckless conduct society should prohibit? If companies know terrorists could use AI systems to cause enormous loss of life or disrupt entire economies, what responsibility do they have to ensure adequate safeguards exist before they release them?
I don’t know the answers, but I know we need to start asking the questions.
Gates’ essay took about half an hour to read. Read it for yourself and then discuss it with your friends and family. Whether you agree with him or not, this is a conversation we all need to have, now. Make a pot of coffee or tea, sit at your kitchen table with those you love, and talk. You’ll no doubt have plenty of food for thought.
“The Turbulent AI Era Is Here. The Choices We Make Now Are Critical” is posted on gatesnotes.com. The podcast’s unabridged transcript, along with a summary, is available at Podscripts.co: “The Ezra Klein Show,” “Bill Gates’s Blunt Warning on A.I.”
